Home Canterbury News Article
Paranoid schizophrenic Marc Traylor left to self medicate despite knife obsession and violent history
00:01, 18 November 2016
A paranoid schizophrenic who launched a frenzied knife attack on his daughter was allowed to self-medicate at home despite an obsession with weapons and a history of domestic violence.
Serious questions have been asked of the decision to trust Marc Traylor to treat himself after a jury decided he was insane when he repeatedly stabbed 16-year-old Kitanna, only stopping when he was shot a third time by armed police.
Canterbury Crown Court heard that the 42-year-old – who once threatened to chop his wife’s head off with a samurai sword – had stopped taking anti-psychotic medication when a community order ended in 2014.
In February last year, in the midst of a manic episode, he was shot three times by police as he repeatedly knifed Kitanna at the family home in The Avenue, Hersden.
He sustained life-changing injuries and watched his attempted murder trial via an internet link from the hospital which is now his permanent home.
After he was found not guilty on Tuesday by reason of insanity, Mr Traylor’s solicitor Sean Caulfield argued there had been “a lapse in care” in his client’s mental health treatment.
“It is essential that families whose loved ones are affected by paranoid schizophrenia are supported and have access to the help needed to keep their loved ones well,” he said.
“Further, regular checks are needed on that individual’s mental health to ensure medication is being taken to avoid manic episodes, where possible.”
Courts had previously heard Mr Traylor had “an obsession with knives” and a fascination with firearms stretching back to childhood.
In 2002, police were called to a domestic incident at the house he shared with his wife Nicole in Maple Gardens, Hersden,where officers discovered a shotgun and live ammunition in the loft.
His solicitor said Mr Traylor had found the weapon when he moved in and decided to keep it out of an “immature boyhood fascination” with guns. Four years later a judge ordered Mr Traylor to go on a domestic violence programme when he threatened his wife with a samurai sword.
The couple had moved to Cumbria to run a pub, but had started to struggle under the weight of debts totalling more than £100,000.
After drinking, Mr Traylor took the sword off the wall and threatened to cut Nicole’s head off.
He received a nine-month suspended sentence after his family pleaded for leniency.
The family moved back to Canterbury and, in 2012, Mr Traylor started to suffer from paranoid delusions.
He was twice detained under the Mental Health Act and subjected to a community treatment order between June 2013 and June 2014.
He stopped taking medication for his condition when the order came to an end, but only told his wife a short time before the fateful night on February 8 last year.
It has since emerged he had a history of failing to take his tablets and hiding the fact from his family and professionals.
After the shooting, Mr Traylor has been left unable to drink, eat, walk or dress independently.
Kitanna, who is now 18, suffered numerous lacerations and a cut liver in the sustained attack, which resulted in part of her bowel being removed.
Mr Caulfield said: “Sadly, the Traylor family has suffered the life-changing consequences of a lapse in Mr Traylor’s mental health care and he may now have to live in a supported unit for the rest of his life due to events of that night.
“The way the Traylor family have responded to such a dreadful event in their lives speaks volumes for their loyalty, courage and the strength of the family bond. Mr Traylor retains the support of all of his family.
“They understand he cannot be held responsible for his actions while suffering from such an illness.
“This has been a particularly distressing case for all concerned and, despite the severity of the charge, Mr Traylor’s family believe that justice has been served.”
Nicole Traylor has made a formal complaint to the Kent and Medway NHS and Social Care Partnership Trust, which administers mental health treatment in the community.
She has been told the incident has sparked a serious case review of her husband’s care.
We asked the Trust if it knew about Mr Traylor’s history with weapons and domestic violence and whether in those circumstances it was appropriate for him to self-medicate at home.
Spokesman Kelly August said the Trust could not comment on whether he was one of its patients.
But she said: “Patients wish to have as fully independent life as possible which is supported by carers, family and friends.
“Part of this rehabilitation includes patients self-administering medication, one of the ways in which they are able to work towards improving their own health and wellbeing.
“We work closely with patients to reach a point where this is possible, which includes a thorough risk assessment process.
“Medication can be given without consent under the Mental Health Act, but the threshold is set by the strict guidance underpinning the use of the Act.”
Advances in technology and a progressively-minded judge meant that Marc Traylor’s trial was possible.
Mr Traylor kept up with proceedings via an internet link using a special CCTV system – even if he could not see the jury which acquitted him.
And his family, who sat in the public gallery, were also able to watch him as he followed the hearing, often in 40-minute takes followed by rest and aided by an expert sitting next to him at a Sussex hospital.
Judge Heather Norton told the jury at Canterbury Crown Court: “This case has been an unusual one in many, many respects, including the way we have tried this case using the CCTV bridging arrangement, an intermediary and other measures.
“As recently as a year ago it would have been thought to have been impossible to carry out a trial in these circumstances.”
The judge added that it was the intention of the criminal justice system to enable defendants or witnesses to participate in a trial “no matter what their disabilities”.
She told the jury that despite them bringing in a special “not guilty” verdict, it had not brought the case to an end.
The judge said Traylor would not be sentenced, but in legal terms there had to be “a disposal”, which will enable him to live a law-abiding life and also protect the public from any risks.
"She ordered reports from psychiatrists and will complete the hearing in February next year.
Mr Traylor’s barrister, Tyrone Smith QC, said there was no chance of any “imminent release” from hospital.
Latest news
Features
Most popular
- 1
‘This rat-run bridge isn’t wide enough - someone will be killed soon’
- 2
Boy, 16, found safe after going missing nine days ago
2 - 3
Only shop in village to shut this week as ‘devastated’ couple leave Kent
16 - 4
A-road shut in both directions after water main bursts
- 5
Mum joined teen son in smashing up ex’s family home and car